Zcash group urges SEC to limit public wallet disclosures

PGPZ asked the SEC to let token issuers verify holdings and fund use without exposing unrelated wallet activity in public disclosures.

Pretty Good Policy for Zcash, or PGPZ, asked the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on Oct. 20 to let token issuers substantiate holdings and the use of investor funds without publishing unrelated wallet activity. The group wants evidence to match the claim being checked instead of requiring complete financial histories.

The submission responds to the SEC’s proposed Regulation Crypto Assets, issued Aug. 18. The proposal would exempt certain offerings of up to $5 million over four years and fundraising of up to $75 million over 12 months from some securities registration requirements. Federal antifraud and antimanipulation rules would still apply.

Issuers using the exemptions would have to disclose token supply, pricing, lockups, distribution methods, insider holdings and release schedules. They would also need to explain how tokens are created or destroyed, how transaction histories can be verified, how offering proceeds will be used, and any related-party transactions or conflicts of interest.

PGPZ identified a difference between proving that a blockchain transaction followed network rules and proving how an issuer used investor funds. A cryptographic proof could confirm that a transfer was valid, while accounting records or other financial evidence could show where the money went.

The group asked the SEC to expressly permit accounting records, zero-knowledge proofs and selective disclosure of relevant documents. Issuers would have to explain what each method verifies and identify its limits. PGPZ also asked the agency to distinguish information for public disclosure from supporting records that auditors or regulators may review.

The submission opposes making wallet keys the standard verification method. A viewing key cannot spend funds, but it can expose a broad record of financial activity unrelated to the claim being examined. PGPZ asked the SEC to clarify that issuers would not generally have to publish complete transaction histories or provide viewing and spending keys.

In remarks dated Dec. 15, SEC Chairman Paul Atkins described zero-knowledge proofs, selective disclosure and wallet design as ways to demonstrate compliance without exposing an entire financial history. He said the views were his own and did not necessarily represent the SEC or its other commissioners.

PGPZ also asked the SEC to apply the same privacy rules to Regulation Crypto Assets, related forms and issuer websites. The proposed instructions for Form 1-CRYPTO would permit redactions when disclosure would be a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy. The instructions specifically list crypto wallet addresses as an example.

SEC staff could request unredacted materials and supporting analysis. The group said this would limit public exposure while preserving regulatory access. It accepted aggregate figures and general descriptions when they still disclose material holdings, relationships, preferential terms and conflicts.

PGPZ said identities should be disclosed when they are material or specifically required, while unnecessary financial identifiers, including wallet addresses, could be omitted. The group said redactions should not remove material narrative information required elsewhere in the disclosure framework.

The SEC docket still listed Regulation Crypto Assets as a proposed rule on Oct. 26, after the Oct. 20 comment deadline. PGPZ’s requests concern possible language in the final rules and do not establish an approved compliance method.

PGPZ did not take a position on whether Zcash is a security. It also did not assume that a Zcash ecosystem organization would use the proposed exemptions or any related safe harbor.

Articles by this author