House Democrats Weigh Crypto Bill With Bigger SEC Role
House Democrats are discussing a crypto market structure bill that could expand the SEC’s role after the Senate failed to advance the CLARITY Act on Sept. 15.
House Democrats are discussing a crypto market structure bill that could expand the Securities and Exchange Commission’s role after the Senate failed to advance the CLARITY Act on Sept. 15. The proposal could reduce the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s role and add stricter ethics rules for government officials, according to industry sources familiar with Democratic staff discussions. The bill has not been published.
The proposal is partly based on a July 2025 amendment from Rep. Maxine Waters, a California Democrat. Her amendment would have imposed new requirements on exchanges, brokers, custodians and other digital asset firms serving retail customers.
The amendment would have required firms to process withdrawals and transfers within 24 hours, except when they had documented, good-faith reasons to suspect fraud. Customer assets would have had to remain in segregated accounts protected from the firm’s bankruptcy proceedings. Firms would have needed customers’ affirmative and revocable consent before lending, staking or otherwise reusing their assets.
The proposal also called for monthly attestations from a licensed accountant supporting cryptographically verifiable proof-of-reserves reports. Customer orders would have received priority over a firm’s proprietary trades. Affiliated market makers and proprietary traders would have been barred from trading against customers on the same platform.
Other requirements included round-the-clock human customer support, notices about specified security breaches within 48 hours, one-page fee disclosures and settlement by the next business day. Firms would have had to disclose the percentage of customers holding an asset at a loss. Insurance or similar arrangements would have covered losses linked to regulatory violations, rather than general market losses.
The House Rules Committee voted 8-4 on July 14, 2025, against allowing Waters’ amendment to reach the House floor. The amendment did not advance.
The Senate’s September text already included limits on commingling customer assets and rules for handling them in bankruptcy, according to a Congressional Research Service analysis dated Sept. 15. It proposed CFTC registration for crypto exchanges, brokers and dealers, along with requirements covering market manipulation, conflicts of interest, customer protection and Bank Secrecy Act compliance.
The Senate text would have preserved SEC authority over investment-contract offerings. It included an exemption for qualifying token issuers raising up to $200 million, subject to disclosure requirements. The text also required certain government officials with large financial interests to divest those interests or place them in blind trusts. Lawmakers remained divided over the scope and enforcement of the ethics provisions.
The Senate vote on Sept. 15 was 49-50 on a motion to proceed, short of the 60 votes required for cloture. Four Republicans voted against proceeding. The vote was not a final vote on the bill, and any revival would require further congressional action.
A Democratic bill could give the SEC authority over additional intermediaries, issuers or customer-protection standards. It could also change how digital assets are divided between SEC and CFTC jurisdiction. Exchanges could face new registration, disclosure, order-handling and custody requirements, while custodians could face higher standards for asset segregation and verification.
A March 2026 interpretation from the SEC and CFTC classified Bitcoin as a digital commodity. The classification of a token and the regulation of an exchange remain separate legal questions. A customer holding Bitcoin on an exchange could be subject to withdrawal deadlines, reserve checks and bankruptcy rules. A self-custody holder would face different legal and operational conditions.
Proof-of-reserves reports can omit liabilities, ownership rights and borrowed assets, according to investor-protection guidance. The Securities Investor Protection Corporation also says non-security crypto assets are outside its protection, even when held at a SIPC-member brokerage. Any equivalent protection system would require rules covering eligible firms, funding and compensation limits.
Any replacement bill would need identical approval in the House and Senate before being sent to the president. Unresolved issues include SEC and CFTC authority, decentralized finance and software developers, compliance costs for smaller platforms, stablecoin incentives and enforcement of ethics rules. Compensation systems and jurisdiction over all spot crypto markets would require legislation.








